Can this servo, stepper or DC motor make this move?
Reduce the move to what the shaft must deliver — peak torque, RMS torque over the cycle including the dwell, speed, and the inertia it reflects — then hold that against one motor. A servo is checked on peak and rated torque, speed and inertia ratio; a stepper on its pull-out curve at the required step rate with a safety factor, the self-start limit and duty; a brushed DC motor on its straight torque–speed line through a gearbox and a thermal rule. The move never changes; only the motor does.
What you need
- the move (step 1) and the mechanism (step 2)
- for a servo: rated and peak torque, rated and maximum speed, rotor inertia
- for a stepper: step angle, the pull-out curve or holding torque, rotor inertia
- for a DC motor: stall torque, no-load speed, gearbox ratio and efficiency